R24 Panthers v Storm - Game Day Thread

MEL
PEN
Penrith Panthers
Melbourne Storm
TELSTRA PREMIERSHIP Round 24
CommBank Stadium
August 14 7:50pm
Penrith Panthers
Round 24
Melbourne Storm

CommBank Stadium
August 14 7:50pm

Game Day Information

:rugby_football: Match Penrith Panthers v Melbourne Storm
:stadium: Venue CommBank Stadium
:clock10: Time Thursday August 14, 7:50pm
:tickets: Tickets Tickets via Ticketek
:rugby_football: Other Matches NSWCUP Penrith Panthers v New Zealand Warriors 16/8 2:00pm1
JFLEGG Penrith Panthers v New Zealand Warriors 16/8 12:00pm1
WNSWP Penrith Panthers v Wentworthville Magpies 17/8 4:00pm2
:sun_behind_rain_cloud: Weather :full_moon: Clear 11ºC (:cloud_with_rain: Chance of Rain: <1% / :wind_face: Wind: N 3km/h)
:tv: Broadcast :tv: Channel 9 (Channel 90 HD / 91 SD) [LIVE]
:tv: Fox League (Channel 502) [LIVE]
:desktop_computer: NRL Live Pass [LIVE]
:kayo: Kayo Sports [LIVE]
:radio: ABC Sydney 702AM [LIVE]
:radio: 2GB Sydney 873AM [LIVE]
:radio: MMM Sydney 104.9FM [LIVE]

(1) NSW Cup and Jersey Flegg Cup to be played at St Marys Leagues Stadium, St Marys NSW
(2) NSW Women’s Premiership to be played at Blacktown Exercise Sports and Technology Hub, Rooty Hill NSW.

:rugby_football: Telstra Premiership | Full Time (GP)

/50px Penrith Panthers 18 Tries Isaiah Papali’i, Nathan Cleary, Scott Sorensen.
Goals Nathan Cleary (3/4)
/50px Melbourne Storm 22 Tries Xavier Coates (2), Joe Chan, Marion Seve, Harry Grant
Goals Nick Meaney (1/4)

MATCH REPORT

PRESS CONFERENCE

HIGHLIGHTS

FULL MATCH REPLAY

PANTHER PRIDE MOTM VOTING

Teams & Match Officials

Telstra Premiership

Penrith Panthers Melbourne Storm
TEAM
Dylan Edwards 1 FB 1 Nick Meaney
Thomas Jenkins 2 WG 2 Grant Anderson
Izack Tago 3 CE 3 Joe Chan
Casey McLean 4 WG 4 Marion Seve
Brian To’o 5 CE 5 Xavier Coates
Blaize Talagi 6 FE 6 Cameron Munster
Nathan Cleary 7 HB 7 Tyran Wishart
Moses Leota 8 FW 8 Stefano Utoikamanu
Mitch Kenny 9 HK 9 Harry Grant
Lindsay Smith 10 FW 10 Josh King
Luke Garner 11 SR 11 Shawn Blore
Liam Martin 12 SR 12 Eliesa Katoa
Isaiah Papali"i 13 LK 13 Trent Loiero
INTERCHANGE
Brad Schneider 14 IN 14 Jonah Pezet
Liam Henry 15 IN 15 Alec MacDonald
Matthew Eisenhuth 16 IN 16 Tui Kamikamica
Scott Sorensen 17 IN 17 Ativalu Lisati
RESERVES
Paul Alamoti 18 RS 18 Bronson Garlick
Jack Cole 19 RS 19 Kane Bradley
Daine Laurie 20 RS 20 Siulagi Tuimalatu-Brown
Mavrik Geyer 21 RS 21 Lazarus Vaalepu
Trent Toelau 22 RS 22 Nelson Asofa-Solomona
COACH
Ivan Cleary HC HC Craig Bellamy

NSWRL Matches

Knock on Effect NSW Cup Jersey Flegg Cup NSW Womens Premiership
:rugby_football: Panthers v Warriors :rugby_football: Panthers v Warriors :rugby_football: Penrith v Magpies
:clock3: Saturday 16/8 1:00pm :clock3: Saturday 16/8 11:30am :clock3: Sunday 17/8 2:00pm
:stadium: St Marys Leagues Stadium :stadium: St Marys Leagues Stadium :stadium: Blacktown Sports & Technology Hub
TEAM
1. Daine Laurie . Nick Murphy 1. Natalia Webb
2. Jesse Mclean 2. Jirah Liddiard 2. Jacinta Tui
3. David Fale 3. Sialetili Faeamanu 3. Litia Fusi
4. John Fonua 4. Tua Patea 4. Brooke Wilkins
5. Asu Kepaoa 5. Potoua Hotere-Papalii 5. Chelsea Blankenstein
6. Jack Cole 6. Zack Lamont 6. Claudia Bush
7. Trent Toelau 7. Tylor Bunting 7. Jade Elford
8. Riley Price 8. Isaiah Scanlon 8. Kahu Cassidy ©
9. Soni Luke 9. Jenson Tuaoi 9. Matilda Vella
10. Austin Dias 10. Josh Ruxton 10. Oriana Epati
11. Mavrik Geyer 11. Zakauri Clarke 11. Abbie Grant
12. Zac Lipowicz 12. Siotame Hansen 12. Loreen Luamanuvae
13. Billy Phillips 13. Bayden Moran 13. Harmony Covacich
INTERCHANGE
14. Billy Scott 14. Kye Raven 14. Chloe Pallisier
15. Niko Apelu 15. Del Wigmore 15. Naomi De Bruine
16. Riley Wake 16. Hokafonu Lemoto 16. Georgia Edwards
17. Sam Lane 17. Jack Attard 17. Ella Walker
RESERVES 18. Julie Tauafao
18. John Sagaga 18. Ahmani Leilua 19. Erin Gunton
19. Hunter Bell 20. Kina Hanisi
20. Compton Purcell
21. Tyson Sangalang
COACH
HC Ben Harden HC Jono Rolfe HC Karen Stuart

:small_red_triangle::small_red_triangle_down: Promoted/Relegated | :small_orange_diamond: Positional Change

Match Officials

Telstra Premiership K.O.E NSW Cup Jersey Flegg Cup NSW Womens Premiership
Referee Ashley Klein TBA TBA TBA
Sideline Official Ziggy Przeklasa-Adamski TBA TBA TBA
Liam Kennedy TBA TBA TBA
Video Referee Chris Butler - -

Referee Success Rate

Referee Active Since 2024 Overall Pen. For Pen. Against Ratio
Ashley Klein 2009 (2/1) 66.67% (26/54) 48.15% 227.5 231 0.98

:mega: Teams and Match Officials have been updated.

TELSTRA PREMIERSHIP

OPPOSITION TEAM

KNOCK ON EFFECT NSW CUP

JERSEY FLEGG CUP

HARVEY NORMAN NSW WOMENS PREMIERSHIP

Might have to venture down to the sainties on Saturday :wink:

Two words should strike dread into the hearts of Penrith and supporters. Not Craig Bellamy. Not Cameron Munster. Ashley Klein. Be afraid. Be very afraid.

1 Like

According to a lot of opposition supporters, he is the only reason we have won last 4 premierships!!! :roll_eyes::man_facepalming:

1 Like

To be fair to Ashley Klein, his percentage has got better as time has gone on. Pre 2020, the win rates were abysmal but 2020 onwards, we have a fairy favourable rating comparably to the rest of the teams.

Ashley Klein Officiating - Penrith Panthers

Year Wins Loss Percentage
2009 1 1 50%
2010 0 0 0%
2011 1 1 50%
2012 1 2 33%
2013 0 2 0%
2014 1 3 25%
2015 1 2 33%
2016 0 2 0%
2017 1 1 50%
2018 1 5 17%
2019 0 5 0%
2020 3 0 100%
2021 4 2 67%
2022 6 0 100%
2023 0 1 0%
2024 4 1 80%
2025 2 1 67%
1 Like

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: Count them - 4!!!

1 Like

As reported by WW Masked Panther & across social media:

Support for Corey

Some fans are planning on a mini-protest of sorts against the suspension handed down to Corey Bocking. They plan on raising their water bottles to the sky in the 50th minute of the match against Melbourne tonight.

1 Like

Thanks, Steve. Interesting stuff, and I agree that it makes his percentages look better. It would be useful to dig deeper, such as to compare the win/loss ratio under Klein compared to the season as a whole; and to consider the results during SoO. But stats can be sliced and diced endlessly, especially when trying to prove a preferred hypothesis.

It’s interesting how most pundits, in their tipping, cited the absence of Yeo as a key factor for Penrith last week. It was cited that, without Yeo, the win/loss statistic was massively different to when he played. But that is an example of the misuse of stats. It fails to consider why Yeo was absent. I’d suggest that most were due to SoO, and hence we would also have been without players like Cleary, Edwards, Martin, Luai, To’o, Crichton, Burton and Koroisau, and that was the primary reason for the higher loss rate. Maybe the tipsters learnt, or took into consideration the Melbourne injury list. Whatever, Yeo’s absence has been given far less examination (or so it seems to me). Hence the oft heard warning – there are lies, damned lies and statistics.

1 Like

Solid first half. We are throwing a few different things at them & mixing it up well. Still can’t work out how their try wasn’t a knock on?

I didn’t think it was a knock on, I thought Coates got the ball back in his hands before he hit Edwards. Fair call for mine.

Good first half, hope we can build on it & get the points.

1 Like

We got a bit loose on the edges in the second half. Now for golden point

2 Likes

Got our pants pulled down!!!

1 Like

Yep. We’ll take a lesson from that. Storm came out with intent in the 2nd half, we didn’t match them for the first 20. We should take a lesson from that, too.

Credit to the Storm. On to next week.

1 Like

:mega: Panther Pride Man of the Match voting is now open here.

Worst refereeing performance since the 2020 grand final.

The script for this was written before we set foot on the field I am afraid

1 Like

Panthers dominating to start the game. Then a few uncharacteristic errors changed the game. It should never have got to golden point.

2 Likes