P3 Tigers v Panthers - Game Day Thread

West Tigers
Penrith Panthers
Witzer Pre-Season Challenge Round 3
Leichhardt Oval
February 20 8:10 PM
West Tigers
Witzer Pre-Season Challenge
Round 3
Penrith Panthers
Leichhardt Oval
February 20 8:10 PM

Game Day Information

:rugby_football: Match Wests Tigers v Penrith Panthers
:stadium: Venue Leichhardt Oval, Leichhardt NSW
:clock10: Time Friday, 20 February 2026 8:10pm
:tickets: Tickets Tickets via Ticketek
:sun_behind_rain_cloud: Weather
Loading weather…
:tv: Broadcast :tv: Fox League (Channel 502) [LIVE]
:kayo: Kayo Sports [LIVE]
:desktop_computer: NRL Live Pass [LIVE]
:radio: ABC Sydney 702AM [LIVE]
:radio: 2GB Sydney 873AM [LIVE]
:radio: MMM Sydney 104.9FM [LIVE]

:rugby_football: Witzer Pre-Season Challenge | Full Time

/50px Penrith Panthers 12 Tries Brian To’o, Paul Alamoti.
Goals Nathan Cleary (2/2)
/50px Wests Tigers 26 Tries Jahream Bula, Heamasi Makasini, Lachlan Broederlow, Luke Laulilii, Heath Mason.
Goals Adam Doueihi (1/2), Jock Madden (2/3)

Postgame Media

MATCH REPORT

HIGHLIGHTS

FULL MATCH REPLAY

+ Coming Soon

PANTHER PRIDE PLAYER RATINGS POLL

Team & Match Officials

Witzer Pre-Season Challenge

Wests Tigers Penrith Panthers
TEAM
Jahream Bula 1 FB 1 Dylan Edwards
Heamasi Makasini 2 WG 2 Thomas Jenkins
Taylan May 3 CE 3 Izack Tago
Starford Toa 4 WG 4 Paul Alamoti
Sunia Turuva 5 CE 5 Brian To’o
Jarome Luai 6 FE 6 Blaize Talagi
Adam Doueihi 7 HB 7 Nathan Cleary
Bunty Afoa 8 FW 8 Moses Leota
Apisai Koroisau 9 HK 9 Mitch Kenny
Fonua Pole 10 FW 10 Lindsay Smith
Samuela Fainu 11 SR 11 Isaiah Papalii
Kai Pearce-Paul 12 SR 12 Kalani Going
Alex Twal 13 LK 13 Isaah Yeo
INTERCHANGE
Jock Madden 14 IN 14 Freddy Lussick
Jack Attard 15 IN 15 Billy Phillips
Alex Seyfarth 16 IN 16 Zakauri Clarke
Sione Fainu 17 IN 17 Luron Patea
RESERVES
Patrick Herbert 18 RS 18 Jaxen Edgar
Tony Sukkar 19 RS 19 Patrick Moimoi
Kit Laulilii 20 RS 20 Tom Ale
Tristan Hope 21 RS 21 Jesse McLean
Heath Mason 22 RS 22 Sione Fonua
Luke Laulilii 23 RS 23 Kurt Falls
Jared Haywood 24 RS 24 Keahn Skipps
Mavrik Geyer 25 RS 25 Jirah Liddiard
Faaletino Tavana 26 RS 26 Billy Scott
Charlie Murray 27 RS 27 Harry Armstrong
Javon Andrews 28 RS
COACH
Benji Marshall HC HC Ivan Cleary

:small_red_triangle::small_red_triangle_down: Promoted/Relegated | :small_orange_diamond: Positional Change

Match Officials

Witzer Pre-Season Challenge
Referee Ashley Klein
Sideline Official Mitchell Currie
Phil Henderson
Video Referee Chris Butler

:mega: Team Lists and Match Officials have been updated.

I was thinking of going to the game, but after seeing the prices I’ll be watching from home. $40 (plus booking fee) to stand on the hill for a trial is ridiculous.

1 Like

AND to potentially see the ‘A’ team for 1/2 the game…..should be 1/2 price and kids free

1 Like

Missing Garner, Sorro, Martin, Henry, Cogger and Cole.

Hard to gauge the performances last week, the team looked liked they had never played together.

We know Ivan doesn’t take these games any more seriously than an opposed hit out. As long as I don’t have to turn the audio off like last week (Kevie declaring the cows as premiers every 30 seconds lol).

$40+ dollars is a rip off, it’s what I used to love about going to the Parra v Penrith trials in years past - it was what $20 or so for the family to get in.

2 Likes

$10 is fee to watch the ‘game’ and $30 to visit the sh!tiest ground of all, you know the same place that dope Darcy Byrne calls the 8th wonder of the world and convinced that dope PM to spend another $40M of taxpayers money on.

2 Likes

Solid first half. Only real worry is if Cleary gets charged.

Lost our way a bit in the second half, when our top players went off.

:mega: Panther Pride Player Ratings Poll is now open here.

Judiciary Update

Nathan Cleary has been charged with a Grade 2 Careless High Tackle. The penalty is a 3 week suspension or 2 weeks with an early guilty plea.

1 Like

It’s horrible that our most paid player, plays the least amount of games.

Whilst it obviously sucks when your main playmaker is out, it may help us a little later during the origin period.

They also have a couple of weeks still to prep for it. Again, very shit but could be worse I think.

Game went pretty well as I expected, although the one on one defensive misses giving them there 2 first half tries was disappointing.

The guess agains from Klien, including one on the last when they had made very little ground that set WTF was crucial, giving the tiges a mountain of ball which gave them some chances.

A couple of fringe players did themselves no favours for the season ahead.

Getting a bit of the rust out was working, until the Cleary incident, which may have some impact for the first few rounds & then the siren went & it was 12-10.

And then after the break the JF/Cup game was played.

Next season, no first 17/19 players should participate in the pre-season “tournament”.

1 Like

For such a talented player, he has had a few brain fades in his career. While enthusiasm can be good, I don’t understand why he gets so carried away.

1 Like

Ground Hog Day - poor ball security, some poor discipline - things you can’t afford when Klein is the referee. Imagine paying good money to watch that. I also agree about Cleary’s brain fades.

I’m not really sure where you are coming from with this???

In all my years of following RL, there has scarcely been a player more in control of his game than NC. He never seems to be panicked and most always makes the correct decision.

His previous suspension came when he dropped Dylan Brown on his head in a tackle that went wrong when Fish let go of Brown, leaving Brown in a precarious position. NC was a victim of circumstances in that one.

The incident on Fri was because NC read the situation and reacted to it. It was just bad luck that the tigers guy lost the ball, went searching for it and in doing that dropped down, meaning that NC’s target area suddenly dropped & hence the contact was higher than planned.

You guys are sure hard markers

2 Likes

That Panthers have said they will go to judiciary to contest the grading of Nathan Cleary’s Grade 2 Careless Tackle charge.

If successful he will be available for the Round 1 clash with the Broncos. If not successful he will be facing 3 weeks on the sidelines.

1 Like

I am not convinced that fighting it is a good idea. How many suspensions have the Panthers managed to overturn, no matter how good the evidence is?

The ‘safe’ option is to just roll over and accept the penalty, but I suggest we are all over the charging and judiciary process as it now works, with almost everyone just accepting the charge and taking the penalty, fearing getting the penalty time. With no judiciary hearing, no-one is testing the match review committee - they just get away with whatever they say.

Last season the Panthers seemed to have had enough of that and pled not guilty to a charge on Sorro, I think it was. The incident looked 50/50 and we obviously though we had a good case, but the panel upheld the charge and he got the extra week - perhaps a, we’ll show them who’s boss here, by the panel.

I had some hope that Captain V’landys would make a call on this as he has done on other matters, saying we don’t want our players missing games due to an incident in a trial, but he has been mute on this one.

I was 50/50 on what we should do in this one, but back the club in challenging this. Likely NC will end up missing the feather dusters game but sometimes you need to back yourselves.